Swinney under pressure as police probe patient deaths at NHS Grampian

Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib said he raised concerns with the Scottish Government several times but was ignored every time.

John Swinney is under pressure to reveal what he knew about a series of avoidable deaths at NHS Grampian as a whistleblower surgeon revealed his attempts to highlight his concerns at the highest level of government and police confirmed they are investigating a number of cases of patients who died.

Dr Mohammed Habib, a practicing liver and pancreas surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, called for the health board to face a corporate homicide investigation as his lawyer dubbed the hospital a “slaughterhouse”.

He said he has been raising issues with agencies including Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) and the Scottish Government for a decade, but has been ignored.

The surgeon revealed a 2022 review of 45 surgical cases, with 20 deaths recorded - 19 which were classed as avoidable.

Hundreds of patients may have suffered “significant harm or avoidable deaths” in recent years, Dr Habib claimed.

Last night, Police Scotland confirmed it received a report in 2024 regarding “several deaths” of patients.

Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”

Dr Mohammed Habibplaceholder image
Dr Mohammed Habib | John Devlin/The Scotsman

Dr Habib said he has previously written to First Minister John Swinney, former first minister Humza Yousaf and former health secretaries Michael Matheson and Neil Gray about his concerns, but was again repeatedly ignored.

The First Minister, who yesterday said the issues raised by Dr Habib were of the “gravest concern”, is now being told to come clean on how much he knew - and when.

The Scottish Government said it had “repeatedly” raised Dr Habib’s concerns with HIS and the health board.

Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra said: “Families were not told, the public were not told, but the First Minister was told.

“Four times Dr Habib wrote to Scottish ministers - including three times to John Swinney - seeking help for the people in his care, yet nothing was done to stop the deaths.

“Enough is enough. The permanent secretary must commission an urgent internal review on who knew what within the Scottish Government and the Lord Advocate must move now towards a criminal prosecution.”

Dr Habib’s revelations came just a week after a damning report into NHS Grampian criticised the health board for poor leadership and culture leading to “repeated and avoidable harm” to patients.

The surgeon called for NHS Grampian to face a public inquiry and a police investigation for corporate homicide, and said the health board’s chief executive, Laura Skaife-Knight, should be sacked.

Dr Habib said: “These cases relating to ARI are, I believe, due to poor decision making, poor technique and recklessness, and they are tantamount to corporate homicide.

“In all the cases that I reported, they were in my opinion guilty of wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient death as an outcome.

“NHS Grampian knew enough to have stopped this carnage.

“Two examples of culpable corporate homicide cases are where two patients were given the wrong operation and then they died. Their families were never told what happened.

“I believe ARI is responsible for possible corporate homicide charges.”

Dr Habib said the expected mortality rate for minor liver and pancreatic cases is 2 per cent, and 5 per cent for major cases. He claims that the mortality rate for major cases at ARI is as high as 20 per cent year-on-year.

He said “hundreds” of patients since 2010 have had complications after being operated on.

The surgeon also said media reports stating there was only one death from surgery at the hospital are inaccurate, and points to a clinical review in September 2022 of 45 surgery cases. From these, there were 20 deaths, 19 of which were classed as “avoidable”.

Dr Habib also said another review in January 2025 concluded it was “no longer tenable” for NHS Grampian to carry out certain pancreatic surgeries and had recommended the procedure “should stop immediately”.

Aamer Anwar, the lawyer representing Dr Habib, said: “He is fully aware that he may lose his career for whistleblowing and may be targeted, but he has taken this step today because 36 years ago, on becoming a doctor, he was taught that taking care of patients must be his first concern.

“Catastrophically, the operating theatre he worked in at times could be described as a slaughterhouse, which killed through incompetence and negligence, whilst not giving a damn for accountability.”

Mr Anwar added: “The mortality rates are unacceptable and have remained so in spite of multiple service interventions to attempt to address issues which may have contributed to mortality.

“There was a catastrophic failure to act whilst Grampian leadership was busy burying evidence behind complex medical jargon.

“They also failed to explain to bereaved families that their loved ones had also died after wrong operations.”

Dr Habib said he had been interviewed by Police Scotland “several times” and referred his case onto the major investigations team in February 2024.

Dr Habib and Mr Anwar called on the Lord Advocate and Police Scotland’s major investigations team to carry out a “fully resourced criminal investigation”.

An independent examination of all possible avoidable patient deaths must also take place, with bereaved families informed of what happened to their loved ones, they said.

Any evidence of gross organisational failures causing death should be passed onto the Crown Office for a possible corporate homicide investigation, the surgeon added.

Last week, a damning report from Health Improvement Scotland (HIS), warned that patient safety was put at risk in a host of bombshell findings into the leadership of NHS Grampian and specific concerns at Dr Gray’s Hospital in Elgin.

Acute medical director, Paul Bachoo and Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, executive medical director, have left their roles at NHS Grampian in the wake of the report while Dr June Brown, executive nurse director, left in September.

Ms Constance has ordered an external intervention team, made up of senior NHS experts in patient safety and clinical governance, to support and oversee progress at NHS Grampian.

The Health Secretary earlier told MSPs the investigation into NHS Grampian was “distressing” and shed light on “longstanding and systemic” problems with the running of the health board.

Mr Anwar said Ms Constance’s statement on NHS Grampian “merely scratches the surface of an industrial-scale cover up” at the health board.

He added: “The measures unveiled by Angela Constance failed to death with a deep-rooted culture of denial, arrogance and incompetence.

“Rather than listening to frontline staff, the priority for some senior management appeared to be saving their own careers rather than patients’ lives.”

Dr Habib said there was “collusion to hide outcomes and ignore the facts to deprive the health board from finding out”.

He said: “NHS Grampian are holding the key to Pandora's box and I believe they are deliberately not opening the box.

“They are avoiding accountability by not being transparent about what damage has been done while promising heaven and earth going forward.

He added: “I love being a surgeon and have given a lifetime to the care of my patients.

“I deeply respect many of the frontline staff who work at NHS Grampian - I have worked with them for 13 years.

“It is time they are supported and listened to by the higher-ups so that things can change for the best.”

A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: “We recognise the courage shown by this whistleblower to raise concerns. Everyone who works in our NHS should feel safe and supported to speak up without fear of detriment.

“Ministers have already committed to transparently setting out all engagement with NHS Grampian in relation to the concerns raised in the Healthcare Improvement Scotland review.

“The government took action and repeatedly raised the concerns of Dr Habib with both Healthcare Improvement Scotland and NHS Grampian. As the HIS review set out last week, there were clear failures in the former medical leadership and in how concerns were being addressed within NHS Grampian.

"NHS Grampian is now subject to a very significant level of intervention and an unprecedented level of support.

“Any criminal investigation is a matter for Police Scotland.”

Laura Skaife-Knight, chief executive of NHS Grampian, commented: "We are aware of the serious allegations raised today. A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing.

“Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered, and NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes.

"We understand the allegations will cause further concern to patients, members of the public and staff.

“It is important we respect patient and employee confidentiality, but we can highlight that where reviews identify issues around patient care, the appropriate duty of candour processes are followed. This includes direct communication with patients and families where required.

“If our consideration of any new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, we will do so. Patient safety remains our highest priority."

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice