Labour must back North Sea oil and AI if it wants to tackle youth unemployment – John McLellan

John McLellan is unimpressed by a crowd of Nimbys, anti-West ultras, Greens, revolutionary communists and others at a protest against AI and data centres

Thousands took to the Royal Mile in Edinburgh last weekend to protest against plans for more than 20 large-scale data centres in Scotland. Picture: Jane Barlowplaceholder image
Thousands took to the Royal Mile in Edinburgh last weekend to protest against plans for more than 20 large-scale data centres in Scotland. Picture: Jane Barlow | PA

Although the sports calendar gods conspired to leave last Saturday afternoon free of rugby and football, I still managed to find myself amongst a large crowd seeking victory, but the opposition was American tech companies posing a threat to our very existence.

That’s how most of those demonstrating against data centres outside the Scottish Parliament see it anyway, not just vast ugly sheds sooking up all of Scotland’s electricity, but enabling artificial intelligence (AI) to destroy jobs and deny our children a future.

Admittedly, some were there purely as Nimbys opposing a planning application on their doorstep, but the gathering of maybe 5,000 people was dominated by the usual anti-capitalist, anti-West ultras, Greens, revolutionary communists and intense young people brandishing angry placards, the same kind of crowd demanding the overthrow of Israel, a ban on fossil fuels, or trans rights.

The neo-Luddite mob

What will be the point, those protesters might ask, of former UK Labour Health Secretary Alan Milburn’s plan to revolutionise the benefits system to get unemployed young people into work or training if Claude and his robot pals have rendered gainful human employment a relic of a bygone age?

Thankfully, that is not quite how either the UK or Scottish governments see AI or indeed data centres. And despite a report commissioned by Scottish Enterprise from the Frazer Nash consultancy pouring cold water, as it were, on the number of long-term employment opportunities large data centres will sustain, they will happen whether the neo-Luddite mob likes it or not.

In any case, according to an Oxford Economics report, there were 266 large operational data centres in the UK as of the end of 2025 − Frazer Nash estimates over 500, including smaller facilities − and the sky hasn’t fallen in. There are three in Edinburgh’s South Gyle alone. But now opposition is gathering momentum, such are the complexities of the planning system and the opportunities for disruption, it could be years before new large-scale centres become reality.

Milburn report risks becoming sidelined

By his own admission, it could be some time before Alan Milburn’s recommendations make a meaningful difference to the lives of a growing number of young people who are ‘not in employment, education or training’, including one in six young Scots. And as those ‘Neets’ get older, their chances of finding an occupation diminish even further, and the problem of persistent worklessness is already as prevalent in older age brackets.

Fast solutions are not available, and the Milburn plan is so wide-ranging and complex – just the executive summary runs to 175 paragraphs − that without determination and the willingness of backbenchers who have already blocked welfare reform to get behind it, there is a high likelihood that most of the proposals will end up gathering dust alongside other unimplemented government-commissioned reports, like the 2011 Dilnot Commission on social care funding.

However, the Milburn Report serves to illustrate the cumulative effects and unintended consequences of so many government policies introduced in isolation of each other. Raising the minimum wage and attacking zero-hours contracts were seen to be “a good thing” for young workers but will reduce opportunities to earn.

Raising employers’ National Insurance contributions wasn’t meant to impact on openings for young people, but made it more costly to take on 21 to 24-year-olds who weren’t apprentices, and has contributed to the crash in graduate training schemes.

To his credit, Milburn doesn’t shy away from this. “Employers do not experience government policy changes one at a time,” he wrote. “Wage costs, employer National Insurance, pension contributions, sickness costs, scheduling rules, business rates and employment protections all feed into the same decision about whether to recruit.”

A bureaucratic thicket

The problem is what to do about it, and while rejecting an immediate cut to National Insurance, much of the rest is in his crosshairs, particularly pension costs, even if his recommendations are predictably dominated by state interventions and a thicket of bureaucratic measures requiring businesses to apply for grants for employment and training support.

Maybe they will work, but his call for changes to an education system which has degraded vocational technical subjects can’t come soon enough in Scotland where the SNP has presided over a shocking neglect of further education.

Refreshingly, the report recognises that private sector job and wealth creation are essential if the programme is not just to be the reshaping of a dependency culture in which taxpayers’ money is just sloshed around different budgets.

“Employer confidence is as fragile as the youth labour market itself,” he said. “Government cannot ask business to create more first opportunities while ignoring the effect its own decisions have on whether those opportunities are viable.”

Too right. He wants 270,000 apprenticeship starts a year for under-25s by 2036, but companies won’t support them out of charity. Cutting the cost of doing business generally, speeding up the planning process for major projects, and reducing taxes to encourage investment are every bit as important but will not appeal to the hard left. However Milburn appears to have read the political reality of a restive Parliamentary Labour Party and avoided turning his report into a more sharply left-right tussle than it is already.

The Rosebank oil field is a perfect example. It could sustain hundreds of North Sea oil and gas jobs when, by the government’s own figures, at least 4,000 jobs were lost last year. Approving Rosebank would show Andy Burnham is serious about creating real jobs on which transferrable skills are based, and which underpins the Milburn plan, while facing down rebels who share blame for the problem Milburn is seeking to solve.

“You cannot solve the Neet crisis by simply pulling a welfare lever,” he said. Or indeed by turning our backs on the North Sea and artificial intelligence.

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice